Port Wings News Network:
The Indian logistics sector has witnessed a sequential recovery in months following the severe disruption in Q1 FY2021 on account of the nation-wide lockdown.
The pandemic induced disruptions had created demand-side and supply-side challenges, however, as the restrictions eased and economic activity revived, the freight availability for logistics players also improved. Although the Y-o-Y volume and revenue contraction continued even in Q2 FY2021, the recovery has been faster than expected, with volumes reverting to year-ago levels by September 2020 and improving thereafter.
According to Mr. Shamsher Dewan, Vice President, ICRA Ratings, “As the economy opened up and industrial, manufacturing, construction and consumption activities picked up pace, freight availability also improved, aiding recovery in the sector. Freight rates also held up in this period. As such, although revenues continued to contract in Q2 FY2021, the pace of contraction mellowed down. As per industry estimates, freight volumes reverted back to year-ago levels by the end of Q2 FY2021, and have improved further in the third quarter, with festive-led demand and specific sectors like e-commerce leading the growth. This trend was visible in E-way bill and Fastag data, which reached pre-pandemic levels in September 2020 and posted Y-o-Y growth in October and November 2020.”
The rail freight traffic has also reported similar trends, although it was able to improve on its year-ago volume levels within Q2 FY2021 itself. The volumes thereafter have also held up, expanding 12% on the base of the previous year during the third quarter so far. The seaways freight traffic, on the other hand, is yet to reach pre-pandemic levels, with supply-side/infrastructure constraints limiting the volume recovery.
Overall, the aggregate revenues of ICRA’s sample of logistics companies recovered sequentially in Q2 FY2021, growing 52% over first quarter levels. The recovery was visible across the various modes of logistics activity. Both Full Truck Load, Less than Truck Load and Supply Chain Management businesses benefited from the pickup in manufacturing activity and consumer demand. Furthermore, the express cargo segment reported healthy momentum, supported by strong traction from the e-commerce sector. However, express segment with dependence on document movement (especially air cargo) continues to remain impacted as offices are yet to open up completely.
During Q3 FY2021, the situation has further improved sequentially, supported by the seasonally strong festive period, which has aided further pickup in consumer demand. Accordingly, freight volumes and consequently, revenues of logistics companies have returned to the growth trajectory. However, sustainability of this demand post the festive season remains to be seen and would remain critical for a sustained recovery in the sector.
With the encouraging trends visible so far, ICRA expects that the logistics sector would be able to pare back some of the volumes and revenues lost during the first quarter, with rural-led sectors and sectors such as e-commerce, pharmaceuticals and auto aiding recovery. Accordingly, ICRA expects the revenue of its sample of logistics companies to decline by 12-14% Y-o-Y in FY2021, despite the 18% contraction reported in H1 FY2021. Nevertheless, in the absence of a successful commercial vaccine, the possibility of a second or third wave, and possible lockdowns imposed to combat it, poses potential downside risks to these estimates.
In terms of profitability, logistics companies have been able to arrest the extent of earnings contraction to a large extent, supported by rationalization of fixed overheads and implementation of cost-control initiatives. Accordingly, the aggregate OPM of ICRA’s sample expanded by 900 bps on a sequential basis and 100 bps on a Y-o-Y basis during this period. However, with the impact of several cost-control initiatives like employee salary reduction, rental waivers, reduction in lorry hire charges etc. being temporary in nature, and with the firming up of diesel prices, ICRA believes that margins are likely to moderate from the highs of 9.6% reported in Q2 FY2021. Accordingly, ICRA expects the aggregate operating profit margins of its sample to be in the range of 6.0-8.0% in FY2021, as against 8.8% in FY2020.
“Despite the sequential improvement reported in Q2 FY2021, ICRA expects the pressure on earnings and credit metrics of logistics entities, especially the smaller unorganized players, to continue over the near-term, given the challenges of overcapacity prevalent in the system even prior to the pandemic. Accordingly, credit metrics of logistics companies are expected to moderate to some extent during FY2021 with Debt/OPBITDA to average at ~2.8x and interest coverage to average at ~3.9x in FY2021, as compared to 2.5x and 5.0x respectively in FY2020. Given the expectations of continued pressure on earnings and credit metrics over the near term, the outlook on the sector remains Negative, till the macroeconomic recovery proves sustainable enough to alleviate these concerns,” concluded Mr. Dewan.
Growth over the medium-term is expected to gain momentum with anticipated increase in demand from segments like e-commerce, FMCG, retail, chemicals, pharmaceuticals and industrial goods coupled with industry paradigm shift towards organised logistics players post GST and E-way bill implementation. Additionally, the sector is likely to witness some consolidation trends, given the rising pressure on viability of small fleet operators. Furthermore, multimodal offerings are likely to gain increased acceptance and traction going forward, given that players offering multimodal services had more flexibility and hence, were better placed to service their customers during the lockdown phase. Given these factors, and the relatively higher financial flexibility available to large organized players vis-à-vis their smaller counterparts, there is potential for increased formalization in the sector going forward.